« 1.011: administrivia | Main | 1.013: more on enterprise flash »

June 26, 2008

1.012: flash drives in enterprise storage

Yesterday I presented a webcast on Enterprise Flash Drives to EMC's investment community, as part of Investor Relations' ongoing Tech Talk series. If you'd like to see it, the slides and replay are available on EMC.com here: Tech Talk for Investors: Flash Drives in Enterprise Storage, but only until July 25, 2008.

Chris Mellor has also reported about this presentation over on Blocks and Files in his "EMC on enterprise flash drives" analysis piece. (Thanks for noticing, Chris - glad you were able to participate).

On a related topic, Network World's Jon Brodkin takes a look into the growing market demand for Flash technology in his article titled Flash storage gets enterprise attention as prices decline. The article provides a fairly comprehensive look at what's going on in the realm of enterprise flash across both storage and server vendors, and it is definitely worth the read.

But I have to admit I was kinda surprised by this quote that Jon included from Michael Workman, president and CEO of Pillar Data Systems:

"The best use of solid-state disk is direct-attached, not in a shared network array. The reason for that is the latencies for solid-state disk are so low that putting it on a network to get at it actually makes the latency of the solid-state disk much worse than it could be."

IMHO, that's a pretty uninformed position to take, especially by the chief executive of an external storage vendor.

While there is indeed additional latency introduced by the storage network, it is not nearly as onerous as Mr. Workman seemingly would have you believe. If it were, we wouldn't be putting gigabytes of SDRAM inside of storage arrays - for as fast as flash is, the latencies of SDRAM is still orders of magnitude faster. And in fact, a Symmetrix DMX-4 can deliver a cached read hit from RAM anywhere from 4-100 times faster than the fastest available flash drive (depending upon the size of the I/O request). And in my presentation at EMC World demonstrated common database workloads where Symmetrix cache coupled with flash drives outperformed even server-based caches of the same size.

Following Michael's flawed logic, RAM caches would only be installed in servers and never in external disk arrays. The reality is that not only do the economics prevent that, as Bob Wambach (head of Symmetrix marketing) aptly explains earlier in the Network World article, but there is a very real performance benefit derived by buffering writes and pre-fetching reads in an Intelligent Cached Disk Array (a club of which admittedly Pillar ain't a member).

As most CIOs realize, When you have expensive resources, like RAM, flash or even disk drives, it is almost always more cost-effective to centralize and consolidate those resources so that their benefits can be shared across multiple systems. It is the reason why we have external storage in the first place, and that's why I'm surprised that Mr. Workman apparently doesn't know that the infinitesimal latency of a (well designed) SAN is far outweighed by the cost, performance and utilization benefits of storage consolidation.

Perhaps he learned that perspective from the Oracle of Sir Larry.Praying



TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 1.012: flash drives in enterprise storage:


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

The comments to this entry are closed.

anarchy cannot be moderated

the storage anarchist

View Barry Burke's profile on LinkedIn Digg Facebook FriendFeed LinkedIn Ning Other... Other... Other... Pandora Technorati Twitter Typepad YouTube


I am unabashedly an employee of EMC, but the opinions expressed here are entirely my own. I am a blogger who works at EMC, not an EMC blogger. This is my blog, and not EMC's. Content published here is not read or approved in advance by EMC and does not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of EMC.

search & follow

search blogs by many emc employees:

search this blog only:

 posts feed
      Subscribe by Email
 comments feed

 visit the anarchist @home
follow me on twitter follow me on twitter

TwitterCounter for @storageanarchy

recommended reads

privacy policy

This blog uses Google Ads to serve relevant ads with posts & comments. Google may use DoubleClick cookies to collect information (not including your name, address, email address, or telephone number) about your visits to this and other websites in order to provide ads about goods and services of interest to you. If you would like more information about this practice and your options for not having this information used by Google, please visit the Google Privacy Center.

All comments and trackbacks are moderated. Courteous comments always welcomed.

Email addresses are requested for validation of comment submitters only, and will not be shared or sold.

Use OpenDNS